The pitch sounds like a bit. George Hardy, a shepherd played by Hugh Jackman, reads detective novels aloud to his flock every night, assuming the sheep have no idea what he’s saying. They understand every word, and they argue about the culprit for hours after he goes inside. Then George turns up dead in his own pasture, the local constable has never closed a serious case in his life, and the sheep decide the investigation is on them.
That’s a movie about a corpse aimed at families, and it should not work as well as it does. What surprises is where the warmth comes from. It isn’t layered on top of the murder to soften it. The grief is the material the whole film is built out of.
The flock believes that sheep who die float up and become clouds. Lily (Julia Louis-Dreyfus) holds that belief hardest, and the film never mocks her for it. The herd also has a shared talent for deliberately forgetting anything that upsets them, a habit played for laughs early and then quietly revealed as the reason nobody in the meadow can talk about what happened to George. Solving the murder requires them to stop forgetting. Watching a group of animals decide to remember something painful on purpose is a strange thing to find moving, and I found it moving.
The other thread that lands is the flock’s treatment of the winter lamb, the smallest and most vulnerable of them, who carries the brunt of the herd’s prejudice. Craig Mazin’s script lets the sheep be genuinely unkind here before it lets them be better. That choice buys the ending its emotion. Nothing in the last act feels handed over for free.
Kyle Balda, whose previous credits are the Minions films, directs a live-action and CG hybrid that mostly stays out of its own way. The sheep read as animals rather than as furry humans, which matters when the camera holds on a face during a scene about loss. Patrick Stewart voices Sir Ritchfield, the aging lead ram whose hearing is going and whose authority is going with it. Chris O’Dowd plays Mopple, the one who remembers everything, which in this flock is closer to a curse. Bryan Cranston turns up as Sebastian. Emma Thompson, Hong Chau, Nicholas Galitzine and Molly Gordon fill out the human side of the village.
Nicholas Braun gets the film’s best surprise as Tim Derry, the constable. The easy version of that part is a dim rural cop who exists to be wrong while the sheep are right. Braun’s Derry starts out overwhelmed and ends up dogged, and the movie treats his eventual competence as a small victory rather than a joke it has to walk back.
The mystery holds together, which is the part I expected to be an afterthought. The suspect pool is fair, the misdirection is real, and the reveal earns its Marple comparison without cheating. I picked the wrong killer with total confidence.
One caution for parents. The PG rating is accurate, but there is a body, the film is honest about where meat comes from, and a few sequences are genuinely tense. Kids under seven or so may have a hard time. Everyone above that will be fine, and the adults in the room will be the ones wiping their eyes.
Compare it to Babe more than to anything animated in the last decade. Same rural setting, same refusal to condescend, same willingness to put death in a family film and trust the audience to handle it. It’s streaming on Prime Video now, and it deserves a much bigger audience than a movie called The Sheep Detectives is ever going to get from its title alone.
gfpods.com 
Leave a comment