Listen

Pick a show

Geek Freaks
Geek Freaks Interviews
Headlines
Fandom Portals
Outlast
Distance NERDing
Hobby Quest

Latest Episode

,

The Train Station Is Where Charles Xavier Wins the Argument

The Fandom Portals Podcast episode art for Magneto vs Charles Xavier, Why I Changed My Mind | X-Men (2000) Explained

Aaron Davies sided with Magneto the first time he watched X-Men. On the newest episode of The Fandom Portals Podcast, “Magneto vs Charles Xavier, Why I Changed My Mind”, he goes back to Bryan Singer’s 2000 film in his thirties, now a father and a teacher, and comes out on the other side of the chessboard.

The rewatch lands a little more than two weeks after Patrick Stewart died at his home in Los Angeles on October 28 at age 86. Fandom Portals already ran a tribute episode to Stewart on November 5. This one stays inside a single movie and walks through it scene by scene, asking which of the two old friends had the better answer to a world that was afraid of them.

Magneto Has His Reasons

Aaron starts where the film starts, with young Erik pulled away from his parents at a concentration camp gate. He reads everything Magneto does afterward through that moment. When Senator Kelly stands in front of Congress pushing a law to identify and track mutants, Magneto recognizes the pattern right away, because he has watched prejudice become government policy before.

Aaron gives Magneto that much, then points to where the logic breaks. Magneto tells Charles, “We are the future, Charles, not them.” A man who survived being labeled inferior turns around and labels humanity the same way, and Aaron calls that hypocrisy. Charles, in the same conversation, says he is still looking for hope, and Aaron marks that as the line where the two men split for good.

He also looks at what each man teaches the people who follow him. Charles gives Rogue a place to belong and a way to understand her powers after months of running. Mystique tells Kelly that people like him are the reason she was afraid to go to school, a reminder that the Brotherhood is made of rejected kids too. Charles trains his students to live alongside humans. Magneto trains his to be strong enough that humans can never touch them.

The Train Station Test

The scene that flipped Aaron is the standoff at the train station. Magneto lifts the police officers’ guns and turns them on their owners. Charles takes telepathic control of Sabretooth and Toad to get Rogue back. Magneto dares him to go further and kill him to save the girl. Charles lets go, and Magneto walks away convinced he has seen weakness.

Younger Aaron agreed with Magneto. Older Aaron sees a man being asked to trade the lives of a crowd of cops for one victory, and he argues that saying no took more strength than saying yes. His line on it: “having the power to make someone do something also doesn’t mean that we should.”

Kelly, Storm and the Limits of Hope

Aaron doesn’t hand Charles a clean win. He admits that watching Magneto’s machine force a mutation on Kelly felt satisfying at first. Then he follows it through. Kelly never gets a chance to understand mutants; the change is done to him, and it kills him. Storm stays with him while his body fails, and Kelly finally admits he is afraid of them. Aaron praises her for answering that fear without hostility, while noting it changed nothing. Kelly still dies, and the registration push is still out there. He leaves open whether Charles is truly protecting his students or whether Magneto is right that some threats need harder answers.

What Magneto Takes From Rogue

At the Statue of Liberty, Magneto remembers seeing it for the first time in 1949 and believing he would find tolerance in America. Aaron uses that memory to show Magneto once had the same hope Charles still carries. Minutes later, Magneto straps Rogue into a machine he knows will kill her. Aaron’s critique is that Magneto spent his life having his choices taken away by other people, and here he does it to a teenager. Logan sits on the other end of the comparison, risking his own life and letting Rogue pull his healing out of him. One man decides what someone else should lose, and the other decides what he is willing to give.

The film closes on the plastic prison, where Charles admits he also fears the day that law passes. Aaron’s read is that Charles sees the same danger Magneto does and keeps coming back to play chess with him anyway, which is his belief in people changing put into practice. Ian McKellen had already worked with Singer on Apt Pupil before taking the role, and the pairing with Stewart carried a film that opened July 14, 2000, and grossed $296.3 million worldwide on a $75 million budget.

Aaron says he now wants to teach his kids and his students to stand up for themselves without turning the people across from them into enemies. He ends the episode by asking listeners which side they took the first time, and whether getting older moved them too.

Sources: PBS NewsHour, SYFY Wire, Box Office Mojo, Wikipedia

New articles and episodes, sent once a week.

Leave a Reply