Thor 5 Rumored to Embrace Grittier Tone with Sam Hargrave at the Helm

In the latest episode of Distance Nerding, the hosts tackled one of the hottest rumors in the MCU; Thor 5 may be heading in a new direction. According to emerging reports and fan speculation, Chris Hemsworth is pushing for action director Sam Hargrave to take the reins from Taika Waititi in what could be the final chapter of his Thor saga.

A New Direction for the God of Thunder

After Thor: Love and Thunder drew mixed reactions for its overly comedic tone, Hemsworth admitted in interviews that the film may have gone too far. “I got caught up in the improv and the wackiness, and I became a parody of myself,” he said. That kind of self-reflection has sparked industry chatter that Hemsworth wants to give Thor a more serious and action-driven sendoff.

Sam Hargrave at arrivals for CAPTAIN AMERICA: CIVIL WAR Premiere, The Dolby Theatre at Hollywood and Highland Center, Los Angeles, CA April 12, 2016. Photo By: Elizabeth Goodenough

Sam Hargrave, best known for directing Extraction and coordinating stunts on Avengers: Endgame, has reportedly been floated as Hemsworth’s choice to direct. Hargrave’s work is praised for balancing raw intensity with emotion, something the Thor franchise could benefit from if it aims to recapture the mythic weight of Thor: Ragnarok or even the earlier solo films.

Marvel’s Next Evolution

While Thor 5 has yet to be officially announced by Marvel Studios, insider reports suggest it is quietly in development—just not with Taika Waititi. Instead, Hemsworth’s influence may bring in Hargrave, potentially shifting the tone closer to high-stakes action and emotional drama. It’s a move that reflects Marvel’s current recalibration following fan fatigue over uneven tones and an oversaturated content slate.

What Fans Can Expect

If the Hargrave rumor pans out, Thor 5 could offer fans a more grounded look at Thor Odinson as he approaches the end of his arc. With Secret Wars on the horizon and many legacy characters preparing for their exits, a stripped-down, high-impact Thor film could resonate with longtime fans looking for emotional closure rather than more gags and goats.

The Distance Nerding crew broke down these rumors with enthusiasm, speculating on how Hargrave’s eye for kinetic storytelling could refresh the character. If Marvel wants to keep audiences invested in its original Avengers lineup, letting a director like Hargrave take the reins might be the right next step.

Final Thoughts

Thor 5 is shaping up to be more than just a sequel—it may be the reinvention needed to restore one of the MCU’s most iconic characters. With Hargrave potentially bringing Extraction-style action to the Nine Realms, and Hemsworth aiming for something more meaningful, this could be a turning point for the franchise.

To hear more takes and behind-the-scenes context, tune in to the latest episode of Distance Nerding, where the team covers this and more from across the geek multiverse.

Sources: