Bon Clay: The Most Loyal Straw Hat That Never Was

In the vast world of One Piece, few characters have left a mark as deep as Bon Clay. Known for his flamboyant personality, swan-themed outfit, and unmatched devotion to friendship, Bon Clay (also known as Mr. 2) stands out not just as a former enemy, but as a true hero. In Episode 192 of the Anime Plus Podcast, hosts Aray and Aunn revisited Bon Clay’s legacy and made the case that he may be the most loyal Straw Hat who never officially joined the crew.

Their discussion is more than just nostalgia. It is a heartfelt reminder of how Bon Clay repeatedly put his life on the line for Luffy and the gang. First, he risked everything in Alabasta, staying behind so the crew could escape. Then again, during the Impel Down arc, he pulled off one of the most selfless acts in the series by impersonating the prison warden to open the Gates of Justice, ensuring Luffy’s escape at the cost of his own freedom.

As Aray put it in the podcast, “He sacrificed himself twice. Not once, twice. That is more than any honorary Straw Hat has ever done.” Aunn agreed, saying Bon Clay had done “way more for the Straw Hats than Vivi ever did. No offense.” It is a sentiment that echoes across the fandom. While Vivi is beloved and often mentioned as the honorary Straw Hat, Bon Clay’s emotional impact and loyalty are in a league of their own.

And fans may not have seen the last of him. According to the podcast, manga cover stories have hinted that Bon Clay is alive and thriving in Impel Down’s mysterious Level 5.5, a hidden sanctuary where he has taken over as the new leader. While these cover stories are not always officially canon, they often serve as Eiichiro Oda’s soft setup for future appearances. With One Piece approaching its final saga, a return for Bon Clay could be the kind of emotional payoff fans are hoping for.

Whether or not Bon Clay ever officially joins the crew, one thing is clear. He has already earned a place in the Straw Hat legacy. The Anime Plus Podcast crew said it best. He is too good for this world. And if there is any justice in the One Piece universe, we have not seen his final bow yet.

For more deep dives and character rankings, check out Anime Plus Podcast Episode 192.